Jump to Recipe -
Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Ice Cream is like having your favorite pudding as a cool, frozen treat!
First of all today, I’m going to tell you that this is probably the most amazing homemade ice cream I have ever tasted. Ever. In my life.
It was so good that I had to have neighbor kids over to eat it so that it would be out of my house. It was too dangerous and I was too tempted to sit down and devour the entire batch myself.
Second, I’m just teasing you here and am not sharing the recipe. Wait… don’t get mad! You can still get the recipe, you just have to head over to my friend Brandy’s blog, Nutmeg Nanny. I’m participating in her August Ice Cream Social and I promise you’ll find the recipe all ready for you over there. I hope you’ll go check it out!
And while I have you here, I want to introduce you to a my friend, a talented blogger / business owner… Jordan, from I’m With Cupcake. Jordan has the most adorable items in store for you, perfect for your next ice cream party or food photo shoot! Make sure to stop by I’m With Cupcake today!
I hate sending you away, but also love sharing my friends with you as well. Enjoy!
(Ahhhh I was afraid after all these years that I might lose this banana pudding ice cream recipe so decided to add it below for you as well. My son would probably kill me if it ever went away and I couldn’t remember it!)
Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Ice Cream
It's like banana pudding but in frozen ice cream form!
Course Dessert
Keyword banana, dessert, ice cream, pudding
Author Kristen
Ingredients
- 1 1/2 cups heavy whipping cream
- 1 1/2 cups 2% or whole milk
- 3 egg yolks
- 1 cup sugar
- 1/4 teaspoon Kosher salt
- 1 teaspoon lemon juice
- 3 Tablespoons instant banana pudding mix
- 2 small bananas sliced
- 1 cup vanilla wafers coarsely chopped
Instructions
In the bowl of an electric mixer, mix the whipping cream, milk and eggs. Slowly add the sugar, lemon juice and Kosher salt. Finally, add the instant banana pudding mix and blend well.
Using a wooden spoon, add the small banana slices and stir to incorporate.
Pour into the freezer bowl of your electric ice cream maker. Turn on and freeze according to the manufactures directions. During the final 10 minutes of freezing, add the coarsely chopped vanilla wafers.
Remove frozen ice cream. Serve immediately or place in a freezer proof ice cream container and serve when ready.
Reader Interactions
Comments
Sounds amazing. I can’t wait to try it! (You know once I’ve gotten my kitchen clean and am getting enough sleep to function 😉 Oh and stop wanting to hold a baby all the time… )
pam says Banana pudding ice cream!!! Yes, please!
- Rachel Cooks says
This looks awesome, Kristen!
- Winnie says
Banana pudding in ice cream form? Yes, please…sounds so amazing Kristen!
- Stacey says
Yum is the word!
OMG…that ice cream sounds amazing! Clicking over to see the recipe now!
Now this is some gorgeous ice cream!! I’m drooling!
- Jen @ Savory Simple says
Can I just say I love that you used a french fry holder for the ice cream cones? Totally genius! And this sounds wonderful.
- Shaina says
I love pudding ice cream, and those spoons are just so cute!
- Ashley says
Such gorgeous photos!! I am all about the flavor of this ice cream. Yum!
- marla says
Stunning ice cream Kristen!! I will hop over to check out Jordan’s goodies as well.
Lovely fabulous ice creams Kristen. And yes, it took me back to my childhood days. :))))
- MikeVFMK says
Love the sound of that ice cream. And that first pic is simply beautiful. Can’t wait to try!
- The BearFoot Baker says
LOVE!!!!
- Jennifer (Savor) says
I already had the ice cream machine out but was trying to think of one more ingredients to add – bananas it is!!!
I’ve been thinking of this ice cream all day since I saw it this morning on Pinterest. Oh my stars alive! Love!
Seriously. This is trouble. TROUBLE!
- fabiola@notjustbaked says
I love supporting the people you love, thank you for sharing!
- Cassie says
This is such a fun ice cream flavor. Stunning photos too!
Love the cones in the wire holder, very cute styling!
- Gina says
I have to tell you- my mom saw this post this morning & just wrote me this afternoon to tell me that she made it immediately & LOVES IT. 🙂 Now it’s on my list.
Such a pretty picture!
- Diana Stanshop says
Banana pudding ice cream is sweet. I love it.
- carrian says
Growing up, banana pudding was one of my favorites. This ice cream has no choice but to make an appearance at my house
- Sues says
What a unique-sounding ice cream! Also? I saw those spoons online the other day and immediately added them to my wishlist. They are amazing!
- theurbanbaker says
an ice cream social?! now, that’s a party I would like to be invited to! Great photos, Kristen!
- Lisa says
Oh my, banana pudding is my favorite dessert and one of my favorite ice cream flavors. A homemade version would be awesome, especially since a certain company that shall remain nameless seems to have changed their recipe for it…that’s how it tastes, anyway.
- Laura Parker says
What a social presentation it is. I love to eat ice cream and banana ice cream is amazing.
- Nutmeg Nanny says
Thank you so much for playing along 🙂 Your ice cream was a huge hit!
This might be the best ice cream flavor ever!
Trackbacks
[…] one that gets really chilly at night), this comforting noodle soup sounds perfect.TREAT YO SELF: Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Ice Cream! I’ll have a double scoop, please.Related posts:High Five Fridays: Weekly Meal Plan (8.03.12)High […]
[…] like those awesome chevron spoons from my banana pudding ice cream post, these yellow bags are also from I’m With Cupcake. Check out their adorable stuff, […]
[…] please let me know.A couple weeks ago my dear friend Kristen over at Dine and Dish posted about Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Homemade Ice Cream. Sounds delectable as her recipes usually are- but I’m trying to cut back a bit. Plus I […]
[…] Have ice cream for breakfast […]
[…] Old Fashioned Banana Pudding Ice Cream […]
